Kashmir, a reality check

Article No. 16
24/August/2019

Jammu and Kashmir is a state in India (It was a state with special status – autonomous till August 5, 2019). It is located in the northern part of the Indian subcontinent, and a part of the larger region of Kashmir, which has been the subject of dispute between India, Pakistan, and China since 1947. Internationally, Jammu and Kashmir is divided between India, Pakistan and China as Indian Administered Kashmir (IAK), Pakistan Administered Kashmir (PAK) and Chinese Administered Kashmir (CAK). Line of Control (LoC) is divided between IAK and PAK. Line of Actual Control (LAC) is divided between IAK and CAK. Political map of Jammu and Kashmir is differently published in India and the rest of the countries. In maps in India, the whole Jammu and Kashmir is the part of India. In maps of the rest of the world, Jammu Kashmir is divided between India, Pakistan and China. It makes confusion among people and spreading untruth about a fact.

Jammu and Kashmir consists of three regions: (a) the Kashmir Valley, which accounts for 54.9% of the population of Jammu and Kashmir, and 15.7% of the area; 96.4% of the Valley's population is Muslim; (b) the Jammu Division, which accounts for 42.9% of the population of Jammu and Kashmir, and 25.9% of its area; 62.5% of Jammu's population is Hindu, and 33.5% Muslim; (c) and Ladakh, which accounts for 2.8% of the population of Jammu and Kashmir and 58.4% of its area; Muslims constitute 46.6% of the population of Ladakh, Buddhists 39.7%, and Hindus, 12.1%. Overall, in the state, Muslims constitute 68.31% of the population, Hindus 28.43%, Sikhs 1.87% and Buddhists 0.89%. Jammu and Kashmir is one of the two administrative divisions of India with a Muslim-majority population (the other being Lakshadweep).

Parliament of India passed two statutory resolutions to recommend that the President issue a notification rendering Article 370 inoperative, and to accept the Jammu and Kashmir Reorganization Bill, 2019 on August 5, 2019. It will reorganize the state into two union territories – Jammu and Kashmir, and Ladakh, are planned to come into effect on 31 October 2019.

Aspirations of India
India’s aspirations on Kashmir is mainly concentrated on political motives rather than the wish of the local peoples in Kashmir. It is evidently understood in India’s stand on the intervention of a Mediator outside India and Pakistan even in midst of Shimla agreement. The United States of America, China, India and Pakistan are interested in affairs of the Kashmir region.

Maharaja Hari Singh became the ruler of the princely state of Jammu and Kashmir in 1925, and he was the reigning monarch at the conclusion of the British rule in the subcontinent in 1947. Jammu and Kashmir had a Muslim majority (77% Muslim by the previous census in 1941). Following the logic of Partition, many people in Pakistan expected that Kashmir would join Pakistan. On 22 October 1947, rebellious citizens from the western districts of the State and Pushtoon tribesmen from the Northwest Frontier Province of Pakistan invaded the State, backed by Pakistan. The Maharaja initially fought back but appealed for assistance to India, who agreed on the condition that the ruler accedes to India.

Under Article 370 of Indian Constitution, Jammu Kashmir has its own constitution and the laws passed by Parliament were applicable to the State only with the State Government’s concurrence. The President was empowered to decide which provisions of the Indian Constitution would be applicable with the state’s assent. Article 35A protected the laws such as bar on outsiders buying property in the State and women marrying non-Kashmiris losing their property rights. These special statuses could only be altered on the recommendation of the Sadar-i-Riyasat (On the advice of Ministers Council) or by ‘Constitution Assembly’. Now, President declared that all provisions of Indian Constitution shall now apply to the State. The Jammu and Kashmir Reorganization Bill, 2019 created two union territories of India – Jammu and Kashmir, and Ladakh.

It was one of the prime promises of ruling political party BJP in their previous general elections in this country. Hyper and religious nationalism of BJP affected secular fabrics of the system of Indian Government. The ruling party gained international support especially from the USA and Israel, because of their common enemy factor. BJP successfully used this opportunity to make political gain and redrawing history of India.

Aspirations of Pakistan
Aspirations of Pakistan also based on politically motive. As it is a hot issue in Indian political vote bank, in Pakistan too. Political leaders in Pakistan win their elections by igniting emotionally motive Kashmir issue. They want to sensitize the issue for getting electoral gains Pakistan politics. It is primarily evident from the press conferences of political leaders in Pakistan and their relationship to separatists groups and terrorists operating in this region. Even though Pakistan and the Kashmir region are Muslim majority, their support to extremist groups in this region unacceptable.

Shia Muslims who dominate the Kargil district in western Ladakh are also unhappy with their inclusion in the new union territory of Ladakh. The reaction among the Buddhists who dominate Leh, the eastern Ladakh district, as well as among Jammu Hindus has been subdued owing to the loss of their rights given by Article 35A.

Voice of people in Kashmir must be heard
Nationhood and patriotism cannot develop by force and compulsion. It must come from the bottom of the heart of individuals in a region. The imposition of nationhood and patriotism will eventually lead to an unstable political situation in the respective area. People in Kashmir have their own opinion about their Government formation and administration. No external force is not required for setting up a political government on a group of people.

Every political region wants autonomy for their administration, especially in the case of disputed regions all over the world i.e. Travancore in 1947, Catalonia in Spain, North Korea, Hong Kong etc. People do not want to attach a string to the distant government rather than their own. Nationalism is a commitment and dedication to their living land, its strength is stronger than steel. Dedication and commitment are not possible to create by Military power or force of guns. Democracy is not for a few people, but the whole hearts of entire people for stable administration. This is the first step for real growth and development.  

By,
Nithin A F
Doing Post Graduation in Psychology
Thiruvanathapuram, Kerala.
Email : nithinaf@gmail.com
www.NithinAF.blogspot.com


24/August/2019

No comments: